Elkhart murder conviction could be overturned - Fox 28: South Bend, Elkhart IN News, Weather, Sports

Elkhart murder conviction could be overturned

Posted:

It looked like the case was closed.

Now, the Elkhart County prosecutor says a judge needs to take another look at a murder case that was solved in 2005.

He says the detective who matched a fingerprint at the crime scene is having second thoughts.

Ninety-four year old Helen Sailor was killed in her apartment at the Waterfall High Rise in Elkhart in 2002.

Three years later, Andrew Royer and Lana Canen were convicted of killing her and sentenced to 55 years in jail.

But Canen maintains she didn't do it.

At a recent hearing, Canen asked a judge to set aside her conviction, saying there was faulty evidence in her trial.

In 2005, during her trial, Elkhart County Sheriff's Department Detective Dennis Chapman identified a fingerprint on a pill bottle in Helen Sailor's apartment as Canen's, but reviewing the print nearly a decade later, he's changed his mind.

A news release from the Elkhart County Prosecutor's office says, "For the first time since testifying against Canen in her jury trial in 2005, Chapman determined that he no longer believed the finger print matched that of Canen."

This change has Elkhart County Prosecutor, Curtis Hill, joining Canen in her request to set aside the conviction.

"Based upon that evidence, I believe it to be appropriate for the court to vacate the conviction and allow us to review the situation and determine where we go from there," says Hill.

Hill says it's something that doesn't happen often, "but I think when it does happen we should take it seriously, review the matter and make a good as decision and result as possible."

If a judge grants the motion, original murder charges will be reinstated.

We called the Elkhart County Sheriff's Department to try and talk with detective Chapman.

We're told the Sheriff will hold a news conference, Monday.

  • Most Popular StoriesMost Popular StoriesMore>>

  • Councilman Derek Dieter calls for clearer Council policy on medical leave

    Councilman Derek Dieter calls for clearer Council policy on medical leave

    Officials say South Bend Common Councilman Henry Davis, Jr. is midway through his first week on medical leave, but the specifics of why he's out are unclear. He hasn't spoken publicly. Instead, all we have to go on is an email he sent the council president saying he needs to concentrate on his health. His request came a little over a week after his DUI arrest. Councilman Derek Dieter wants the full council to meet and clarify the leave of absence process.More >>
    Officials say South Bend Common Councilman Henry Davis, Jr. is midway through his first week on medical leave, but the specifics of why he's out are unclear. He hasn't spoken publicly. Instead, all we have to go on is an email he sent the council president saying he needs to concentrate on his health. His request came a little over a week after his DUI arrest. Councilman Derek Dieter wants the full council to meet and clarify the leave of absence process.More >>
  • New ownership and volunteers working to restore historic Eden Springs Park in Benton Harbor

    New ownership and volunteers working to restore historic Eden Springs Park in Benton Harbor

    They call it a labor of love. A big piece of Michiana history, sat vacant for decades. Now, dedicated volunteers are working to bring it back to life.Eden Springs Park was opened by the House of David religious commune in 1908 and closed in the early 1970's. Until 2009 it was left to let nature take it over, until new owners said they couldn't let it happen.More >>
    They call it a labor of love. A big piece of Michiana history, sat vacant for decades. Now, dedicated volunteers are working to bring it back to life.Eden Springs Park was opened by the House of David religious commune in 1908 and closed in the early 1970's. Until 2009 it was left to let nature take it over, until new owners said they couldn't let it happen.More >>
  • Drinking water concerns for Granger and Gilmer Park addressed at a meeting Wednesday

    Drinking water concerns for Granger and Gilmer Park addressed at a meeting Wednesday

    Nitrates, nicotine, deet, and other toxins were discovered in St. Joe County water in December 2013, following a year-long study. Northeast Granger and Gilmer Park on the south side of South Bend are the areas affected by the contamination. The county health department points to septic systems as the cause for the problem. A group of experts met Wednesday night just to lay-out the first steps in cleaning up the drinking water. St. Joe County's Environmental Health Director, Marc Nelson, says ...More >>
    Nitrates, nicotine, deet, and other toxins were discovered in St. Joe County water in December 2013, following a year-long study. Northeast Granger and Gilmer Park on the south side of South Bend are the areas affected by the contamination. The county health department points to septic systems as the cause for the problem. A group of experts met Wednesday night just to lay-out the first steps in cleaning up the drinking water. St. Joe County's Environmental Health Director, Marc Nelson, says ...More >>
Powered by WorldNow

Fox 28

WSJV-TV FOX 28
58096 County Road 7, South
Elkhart, IN 46517

Switchboard: 574.679.9758
News Phone: 574.679.4545
Station Fax: 574.294.1267
Email: fox28news@fox28.com

All content ©Copyright 2000 - 2014 WorldNow and WSJV. All Rights Reserved.
For more information on this site, please read our Privacy Policy and Terms of Service and Mobile Privacy Policy & Terms of Service.

Persons with disabilities who need assistance with issues relating to the content of this station's public inspection file should contact Administrative Assistant Heather Stewart at (574) 343-5310. Questions or concerns relating to the accessibility of the FCC's online public file system should be directed to the FCC at 888-225-5322, at 888-835-5322 (TTY) or at fccinfo@fcc.gov.